Home News Trial: Suspended CJN Onnoghen closes his defence

Trial: Suspended CJN Onnoghen closes his defence

109
SHARE

The suspended Chief Justice of Nigeria, Justice Walter Onnoghen, closed his defence on Wednesday, at the Code of Conduct Tribunal, Abuja, in his ongoing trial on the charges bordering on assets declaration breaches, after calling his driver of 20 years as his witness.

The lead counsel to Onnoghen, Chief Chris Uche (SAN), told the court that after taking a deep consideration, the defence had closed its case.

“Pursuant to paragraph 14 of the Practice Direction of CCT we will be applying to file our final written addresses.’’

Uche asked the court to give the counsel in the matter 14 days within which to file their written addresses.

He also applied to be obliged with the proceedings before the tribunal.

The prosecution counsel, led by Aliyu Umar, SAN, also prayed the court to accord counsel enough time to file their written addresses.

“Because time for filing of written address is not expressively provided for in the Practice Direction, that makes it a matter of discretion of the court,’’ Umar said.

Meanwhile, the Chairman of the tribunal. Mr Danladi Umar, said the tribunal had given the defence three working days from April 4 to April 8 to file their address.

The chairman also said the prosecution should file their address from April 9 to April 11.

He adjourned the case until April 15 for adoption of written addresses.

Onnoghen’s 60-year-old driver, Lawal Busari, had appeared at the tribunal as the first defence witness on Monday after the March 29 ruling dismissing the defendant’s no-case submission.

The tribunal issued a subpoena on a director at the Code of Conduct Bureau, Mrs. Theresa Nwafor, to appear as the CJN’s second witness on Wednesday.

The order followed an earlier oral application by Onnoghen’s lawyer, Chief Adegboyega Awomolo (SAN), on Monday which the prosecuting counsel, Umar, did not oppose.

In a bench ruling, the tribunal chairman ordered the issuance and service of subpoena on Nwafor directing her to appear at 10 a.m. on Wednesday.

Asked by the tribunal chairman, Awomolo said during Monday’s proceedings that the defence had proposed to call “two or three witnesses for now”.

With Busari’s testimony concluded on Monday, it was not clear if the defence would close its case after Nwafor’s evidence on Wednesday or whether the suspended CJN himself would testify.

Testifying earlier, Busari, who described himself as the Chief Driver/Mechanic at the Supreme Court of Nigeria, said Onnoghen submitted his assets declaration form in 2010.

This was contrary to one of the six counts preferred against Onnoghen that he did not declare his assets between 2005 and 2016.

Busari said the suspended CJN obtained his asset declaration form from the Asokoro office of Code of Conduct Bureau in Abuja on July 28, 2010, and submitted same after completing it on Nov. 4, 2010.

He said he drove Onnoghen to the CCB office where he (CJN) encouraged him to obtain his own form.

He added that on Nov. 3, 2010, Onnoghen gave him N200 to pay as the oath fee for the assets declaration at the treasury office of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory.

He said he was given a receipt by the cashier which he later handed over to Onnoghen.

The defence team sought to tender the said receipt but the prosecution objected, saying it was not admissible on, among other grounds, that its authenticity was in doubt.

But the tribunal chairman overruled the objection and admitted the document as an exhibit, adding that the “weight” to be attached to it would be determined.

Continuing his testimony, Busari said he submitted his completed form and that of Onnoghen at the CCB office in Asokoro, Abuja on Nov. 4, 2010.

Fielding questions from Awomolo, he said, “I don’t know the name of the person who collected the forms from me but I know she was a woman, who was light in complexion.

“She received my form and that of my lordship.

“I was not given any acknowledgment copy that day. I was asked to come for it when it was ready.”

He said he later went back and collected the acknowledgment slip for his own submitted form.

Again, Awomolo sought to tender Busari’s acknowledgment slip.

This time, the objection raised by the prosecutor to the effect that it was not relevant to the proceedings was sustained and the document was rejected by the tribunal.

Under cross-examination by the prosecutor, Busari confirmed that he had been driving Onnoghen since 1999 while the judge was still serving on the bench of the Court of Appeal.

He confirmed that he drove him to obtain his asset declaration form in 2010.

But he said he did not go with the suspended CJN to the CCB office in 2005 to obtain the form for the assets declaration made by the judge after his appointed to the Supreme Court bench in that yearThe suspended Chief Justice of Nigeria, Justice Walter Onnoghen, closed his defence on Wednesday, at the Code of Conduct Tribunal, Abuja, in his ongoing trial on the charges bordering on assets declaration breaches, after calling his driver of 20 years as his witness.

The lead counsel to Onnoghen, Chief Chris Uche (SAN), told the court that after taking a deep consideration, the defence had closed its case.

“Pursuant to paragraph 14 of the Practice Direction of CCT we will be applying to file our final written addresses.’’

Uche asked the court to give the counsel in the matter 14 days within which to file their written addresses.

He also applied to be obliged with the proceedings before the tribunal.

The prosecution counsel, led by Aliyu Umar, SAN, also prayed the court to accord counsel enough time to file their written addresses.

“Because time for filing of written address is not expressively provided for in the Practice Direction, that makes it a matter of discretion of the court,’’ Umar said.

Meanwhile, the Chairman of the tribunal. Mr Danladi Umar, said the tribunal had given the defence three working days from April 4 to April 8 to file their address.

The chairman also said the prosecution should file their address from April 9 to April 11.

He adjourned the case until April 15 for adoption of written addresses.

Onnoghen’s 60-year-old driver, Lawal Busari, had appeared at the tribunal as the first defence witness on Monday after the March 29 ruling dismissing the defendant’s no-case submission.

The tribunal issued a subpoena on a director at the Code of Conduct Bureau, Mrs. Theresa Nwafor, to appear as the CJN’s second witness on Wednesday.

The order followed an earlier oral application by Onnoghen’s lawyer, Chief Adegboyega Awomolo (SAN), on Monday which the prosecuting counsel, Umar, did not oppose.

In a bench ruling, the tribunal chairman ordered the issuance and service of subpoena on Nwafor directing her to appear at 10 a.m. on Wednesday.

Asked by the tribunal chairman, Awomolo said during Monday’s proceedings that the defence had proposed to call “two or three witnesses for now”.

With Busari’s testimony concluded on Monday, it was not clear if the defence would close its case after Nwafor’s evidence on Wednesday or whether the suspended CJN himself would testify.

Testifying earlier, Busari, who described himself as the Chief Driver/Mechanic at the Supreme Court of Nigeria, said Onnoghen submitted his assets declaration form in 2010.

This was contrary to one of the six counts preferred against Onnoghen that he did not declare his assets between 2005 and 2016.

Busari said the suspended CJN obtained his asset declaration form from the Asokoro office of Code of Conduct Bureau in Abuja on July 28, 2010, and submitted same after completing it on Nov. 4, 2010.

He said he drove Onnoghen to the CCB office where he (CJN) encouraged him to obtain his own form.

He added that on Nov. 3, 2010, Onnoghen gave him N200 to pay as the oath fee for the assets declaration at the treasury office of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory.

He said he was given a receipt by the cashier which he later handed over to Onnoghen.

The defence team sought to tender the said receipt but the prosecution objected, saying it was not admissible on, among other grounds, that its authenticity was in doubt.

But the tribunal chairman overruled the objection and admitted the document as an exhibit, adding that the “weight” to be attached to it would be determined.

Continuing his testimony, Busari said he submitted his completed form and that of Onnoghen at the CCB office in Asokoro, Abuja on Nov. 4, 2010.

Fielding questions from Awomolo, he said, “I don’t know the name of the person who collected the forms from me but I know she was a woman, who was light in complexion.

“She received my form and that of my lordship.

“I was not given any acknowledgment copy that day. I was asked to come for it when it was ready.”

He said he later went back and collected the acknowledgment slip for his own submitted form.

Again, Awomolo sought to tender Busari’s acknowledgment slip.

This time, the objection raised by the prosecutor to the effect that it was not relevant to the proceedings was sustained and the document was rejected by the tribunal.

Under cross-examination by the prosecutor, Busari confirmed that he had been driving Onnoghen since 1999 while the judge was still serving on the bench of the Court of Appeal.

He confirmed that he drove him to obtain his asset declaration form in 2010.

But he said he did not go with the suspended CJN to the CCB office in 2005 to obtain the form for the assets declaration made by the judge after his appointed to the Supreme Court bench in that year